• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Hyderus

Hyderus Cyf and Hyderus Teoranta

Pandemicast
  • Home
  • Tell the Truth
    • Videos
  • About us
    • Access to innovative medicines
    • New Work in India
    • Mark Chataway
    • We pay our taxes
    • Our approach to managing risk perception and crises
    • African journalists we respect
  • Customers
  • Expertise
    • Development and Politics
      • Assessing science policy in 48 African countries
      • The future of European development funding
      • The link between family planning and climate change
      • What are the influence networks in health?
    • Knowledge Transfer and Capacity Building
      • For senior executives
      • For the online world
      • To manage international politics
    • Public Health
      • Drivers and barriers for new vaccines
    • Strategic Planning
      • Avoiding a crisis in the Middle East
      • Developing BRICS countries as donors
      • For an international organisation in India
      • Increasing immunization coverage in central India
      • Setting up systems for issues management
    • Treatment Decisions
      • How to get healthcare systems to care for older women
      • Immunisation for adults
      • Stakeholders and corporate social responsibility
  • Contact
  • Blog
    • What we’re thinking
    • Our World
    • Staff blog
  • Flexible Pricing Plan

Reactions to the Bongo Bongo Land controversy #aid #development

August 11, 2013 by Mark Chataway Leave a Comment

It’s been a hot week for popular discussions of overseas development assistance (ODA or “aid”) in the UK . The trigger was a speech by Godfrey Bloom of the UK Independence Party in which he talked about “aid for Bonga Bonga Land” funding Ferraris and luxury apartments in Paris. Bloom is a frequently-drunken, always embarrassing Member of the European Parliament who was, eventually, forced to apologise by his party leader. Steve Richards think the comments will help the Conservative Party overall and , incidentally, to stick to its commitment to keep ODA at 0.7%; I’m not so sure.

Bloom’s remarks allowed lots of commentators to disown his language but to embrace some of the sentiments. Andrew Gilligan, the journalist at the centre of allegations that the Blair government hyped the threat from Iraq before going to war, writes in the right-wing Sunday Telegraph that British aid has gone off the tracks. His arguments are exactly those that we said would be used by opponents of ODA in our Report on the Future of European ODA. They centre on aid to middle-income countries.

The consensus response of the big three parties was put beautifully in an imaginary letter from Mr Ray Ban,  the Ambassador of Bongo Bongo Land, to the Prime Minister (written, in reality, by Paul Vallely in the reliably-internationalist Independent on Sunday).  Vallely’s piece is much more coherent and much better written than Gilligan’s but it is still strangely unconvincing. No, British ODA does not fund Ferraris or luxury flats directly. However, British aid is spent to provide health for Nigerians while the country’s own, very wealthy, government devotes less than two percent of GDP to funding public health services. There are lots of examples of best practice but they tend to come from the poorest countries where donors have more power to nudge the pattern of spending: Malawi, for example, where foreign investment in education and health has been matched by domestic budget commitments.

To defend ODA in the medium term, we must, address the core question: where does responsibility lie for the very poor in increasingly-rich countries? If it is to be shared between donors and emerging economies, taxpayers in the decreasingly-rich countries will want assurances that it is being shared fairly.

bloom

 

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Filed Under: Featured Tagged With: aid, Development, foreign policy, ODA

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Featured (206)
  • Our craft (22)
  • Staff blog (56)
access to medicines Africa Chris Nial climate change communications consultancy coronavirus COVID-19 Development Donald Trump environment foreign policy Global Health Progress global warming green energy health healthcare health policy HIV Hyderus india Mark Chataway ODA PandemiCast patents pharmaceutical industry public health vaccination vaccines wales WHO

Hyderus on Twitter

Tweets by Hyderus

Hyderus on Facebook

Videos

The Three Commitments
Why Consultants end up not telling the truth
The worst kind of market research interviewing technique ever
Why bright people can’t explain themselves
More videos

Clients

 
 
 

Footer

Looking For?

  • Our World
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use

Recent Posts

  • Accessible healthcare could aid climate crisis in rainforest communities
  • Climate change impact has the potential to regress cancer progress through healthcare disruption, according to study
  • Vaccines and COVID-19: Frans van den Boom speaks to Hyderus and Baird’s CMC

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Copyright © 2021 Hyderus. All rights reserved. Sitemap

  • Home
  • Tell the Truth
    ▼
    • Videos
  • About us
    ▼
    • Access to innovative medicines
    • New Work in India
    • Mark Chataway
    • We pay our taxes
    • Our approach to managing risk perception and crises
    • African journalists we respect
  • Customers
  • Expertise
    ▼
    • Development and Politics
      ▼
      • Assessing science policy in 48 African countries
      • The future of European development funding
      • The link between family planning and climate change
      • What are the influence networks in health?
    • Knowledge Transfer and Capacity Building
      ▼
      • For senior executives
      • For the online world
      • To manage international politics
    • Public Health
      ▼
      • Drivers and barriers for new vaccines
    • Strategic Planning
      ▼
      • Avoiding a crisis in the Middle East
      • Developing BRICS countries as donors
      • For an international organisation in India
      • Increasing immunization coverage in central India
      • Setting up systems for issues management
    • Treatment Decisions
      ▼
      • How to get healthcare systems to care for older women
      • Immunisation for adults
      • Stakeholders and corporate social responsibility
  • Contact
  • Blog
    ▼
    • What we’re thinking
    • Our World
    • Staff blog
  • Flexible Pricing Plan
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.

Cookies

This site uses cookies: Find out more.